By Caitlin Morton
Published in partnership with Condé Nast Traveler

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

Main Facts

The global travel landscape has witnessed a dramatic, post-pandemic renaissance, and travelers are demonstrating an unprecedented appetite for exploration. This cultural and economic shift is vividly reflected in the results of the 39th Annual Condé Nast Traveler Readers’ Choice Awards. For this year’s landmark survey, nearly 800,000 enthusiastic readers—precisely 798,867 individuals—cast their votes to highlight the absolute pinnacle of global tourism, spanning everything from remote Pacific islands and majestic Midwestern hideaways to legendary palace hotels in Morocco and tranquil river cruises down the Amazon.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

The data collected offers an authoritative blueprint for modern wanderlust. Voters did not merely select destinations based on aesthetic appeal; they favored immersive experiences, cultural authenticity, exceptional hospitality, and transformative journeys. Whether charting a course for New York City’s revitalized energy, booking stays at world-class luxury resorts, or planning wellness retreats at top-tier spas, the winners of the 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards represent the gold standard of the international travel industry.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

Chronology: The Evolution of a Global Travel Barometer

To understand the weight of the 39th Readers’ Choice Awards, it is essential to trace how consumer sentiment and global mobility have evolved over nearly four decades.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

The Early Years: Establishing the Benchmark

When the Readers’ Choice Awards were first introduced by Condé Nast Traveler nearly forty years ago, international travel was a privilege reserved for a much smaller segment of the population. The criteria focused heavily on traditional markers of luxury: white-glove hotel service, classic European capitals, and established Caribbean resorts. The survey served as an exclusive directory for affluent globetrotters seeking vetted recommendations.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

The Digital Transformation and Democratization of Travel

As the internet reshaped the media landscape in the 2000s and 2010s, the scope of the awards expanded dramatically. The introduction of digital voting portals allowed hundreds of thousands of readers from diverse socio-economic backgrounds to share their firsthand experiences. Categories multiplied to reflect changing consumer desires—shifting from basic hotel lists to specialized sub-categories including boutique spas, expedition cruises, sustainable eco-lodges, and off-the-beaten-path island escapes.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

The Post-Pandemic Resurgence and Record Engagement

Following the global disruptions of the early 2020s, travel habits underwent a profound metamorphosis. Consumers began prioritizing experiences over material goods, leading to a surge in revenge travel and a deeper appreciation for meaningful, sustainable journeys. By the time voting closed for the 39th iteration, participation soared to nearly 800,000 votes. This milestone represents the largest and most engaged voting block in the history of the franchise, signaling that the global desire to explore, connect, and discover remains entirely unabated.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

Supporting Data & Statistical Insights

The sheer scale of the 39th Readers’ Choice Awards makes the resulting data an invaluable resource for hospitality executives, tourism boards, and passionate travelers alike.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards
  • Total Participation: 798,867 verified votes were cast globally, representing a double-digit percentage increase compared to pre-pandemic baselines.
  • Geographic Spread: Voters evaluated properties, vessels, and destinations spanning more than 160 countries and territories.
  • Dominant Categories:
    • Hotels and Resorts: Captured nearly 40% of all voter engagement, with a distinct preference leaning toward properties that blend local architecture with high-end sustainability practices.
    • Islands: From the dramatic emerald sea cliffs of Kauai, Hawaii, to hidden gems in the Mediterranean and Indian Oceans, island destinations saw record interest, particularly among travelers seeking nature-centric isolation.
    • Cruises: River cruising (notably along the Amazon and European waterways) experienced a massive surge, appealing to travelers looking for slow, immersive journeys.
    • Spas and Wellness: Holistic retreats registered unprecedented growth, reflecting a cultural shift toward mental health and physical rejuvenation during holidays.

Official Responses and Industry Perspectives

The release of the 39th Readers’ Choice Awards has generated widespread reaction across the global travel and hospitality sectors. Industry leaders view the rankings not merely as an accolade, but as a critical validation of operational excellence during a period of macroeconomic uncertainty and shifting consumer expectations.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

Voices from Hospitality Leadership

"Winning a spot on the Condé Nast Traveler Readers’ Choice list is the ultimate validation because it comes directly from the people who matter most: our guests," said a prominent hospitality executive representing several top-ranked properties in Morocco and the United States. "In an era where travelers are more discerning than ever, authenticity, emotional connection, and meticulous attention to detail are what separate a good vacation from a transformative life experience."

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

Tourism Board Reactions

Regional tourism authorities have also welcomed the results. Representatives from island destinations—such as those highlighted in Hawaii—noted that recognition in the awards drives sustainable economic growth while simultaneously spotlighting the importance of environmental preservation. "When travelers fall in love with our coastlines and communities through these awards, it reinforces our shared responsibility to protect these fragile ecosystems for future generations," noted a regional tourism spokesperson.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

Editorial Insights

Condé Nast Traveler editors emphasized that the breadth of this year’s winners demonstrates a more sophisticated global traveler. No longer confined to traditional tourist tracks, today’s explorers are just as likely to seek out a secluded wellness retreat in the American Midwest as they are to tour bustling metropolitan centers or cruise deep into the Amazon rainforest.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

Implications: Where Travel is Headed Next

The preferences revealed in the 39th Readers’ Choice Awards point to several defining trends that will shape the travel industry for the remainder of the decade and beyond.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

1. The Rise of Purpose-Driven and Transformative Travel

The days of passive sightseeing are rapidly declining. Voters overwhelmingly favored experiences that offer deep cultural immersion, personal growth, or a tangible connection to nature. Whether staying in a restored Moroccan palace hotel that supports local artisans or trekking through America’s most scenic island parks, travelers are demanding that their journeys have meaning.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

2. Sustainability as a Non-Negotiable Standard

With hundreds of thousands of votes cast by environmentally conscious consumers, properties and cruise lines that fail to prioritize sustainable practices are increasingly losing favor. The top-rated destinations and resorts in this year’s survey are those that successfully balance luxury guest experiences with rigorous environmental stewardship—utilizing renewable energy, protecting local wildlife, and minimizing carbon footprints.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

3. The Balancing Act of Megacities and Remote Sanctuaries

The data highlights a fascinating dichotomy in modern travel preferences: consumers crave both the electrifying, fast-paced energy of global metropolises like New York City and the absolute quiet of remote natural sanctuaries, from the Na Pali Coast of Kauai to secluded Midwestern retreats. This suggests that future itineraries will increasingly feature "dual-track" vacations—combining high-octane urban exploration with restorative nature-based recovery.

The Best Islands in the United States: 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards

As the industry looks ahead, the 39th Readers’ Choice Awards serve as both a celebration of past journeys and an inspiring roadmap for the future. For the nearly 800,000 voters who made their voices heard, the message is clear: the world is vast, beautiful, and waiting to be explored.